Vet Blog

03/05/09

Did Arizona Officials Contribute to Death of Jaguar?
Dr. Eric Barchas, DVM

jaguar_sitting-edit1.jpgI was saddened by an article that appeared on Livescience recently. The USA’s only known wild jaguar has died.

A rare jaguar captured and collared in Arizona two weeks ago was euthanized after falling ill, state game officials said.

The jaguar was the only one spotted in the United States in more than a decade. Officials captured the cat Feb. 18 as part of a program to study bears and mountain lions. A procedure had previously been put in place to attach a satellite collar to any such fortuitously captured jaguar, so wildlife experts could monitor its movements to learn more about the extremely rare creatures.

The jaguar stopped moving, however.

Biologists found the male jaguar, brought it to a zoo, and he was put down that day. Officials say the cat, named Macho B, suffered kidney failure, common among old cats.

Macho B was first spotted by automatic trail cameras in 1996 when he was about age 2 or 3. He was thought to be 15 or 16 – relatively old for jaguars – when he was euthanized.

The article continues:

The cat had dropped from 118 pounds at the time of his capture last month to just 99.5 pounds Monday . . . [a] necropsy (animal autopsy) will be performed to learn more about the jaguar’s condition and to possibly provide clues to how long the animal had been sick.

In a statement released yesterday, officials did not say whether . . . they might or might not have contributed the animal’s demise.

The Arizona officials may be keeping mum about their role in Macho B’s death, but I will weigh in. What follows is speculation based on my experiences working with big cats in California and Botswana.

To work with a jaguar safely, the cat must be anesthetized. Chemical restraint (as anesthesia is often called by wildlife experts) of a wild cat generally involves loading drugs into a syringe dart and firing the dart at the cat.

All anesthetic agents have the potential to trigger low blood pressure. Low blood pressure can damage the kidneys. This especially true of kidneys that are already compromised by pre-existing disease. Veterinarians generally prefer to run blood tests on patients before anesthesia so that the kidneys and other organs can be assessed. Obviously, it is not possible to run blood tests on a wild jaguar before darting him.

I suspect that Macho B, like many elderly cats, was suffering from kidney disease before he was captured by Arizona officials. The anesthetic procedure stressed his already weak kidneys and pushed them over the edge, causing his health to fail rapidly.

I should stress that I do not believe that the officials who captured Macho B caused his death. The kidney disease was going to catch up with the jaguar eventually. However, I do believe that Macho B’s death was accelerated by the procedure.

Finally, I am in no way convinced that the Arizona officials did anything wrong. Everything I have read indicates that their capture strategy and techniques were well thought out and executed (although it is not clear whether Macho B’s advanced age was considered when the decision was made to capture him).

The people who captured Macho B certainly were animal lovers. I have a strong hunch that they are utterly devastated by his death.

Photo credit: Colin Burnett

Share this entry with your pawple anywhere:

See related Vet Blog entries:
10/13/08

How Effective is Anesthesia-Free Dental Work?
Dr. Eric Barchas, DVM

796px-azawakh_k9.jpgI was wondering if anaesthesia-free teeth cleaning
is as effective as traditional cleanings? I brush
my 13-year-old dog’s teeth daily in addition to
six-month cleanings (anaesthesia-free) and it all
seems good. I just wanted to make sure there
wasn’t someting I was missing.
Thanks!

Hedy
Los Angeles, CA

Anesthesia-free dental work is sometimes touted as a substitute for procedures performed under anesthesia by a veterinarian’s staff. Many people reason that they do not need anesthesia to have their teeth cleaned. Why should it be different for pets?

Also, clients often express surprise when I recommend anesthetic dental work for their pets. I cannot count the number of times people have said, “But Fluffy just had his teeth cleaned two years ago!”

What you must remember is that pets don’t brush their teeth. Remember as well that pets age five to seven human years for each year that passes.

If you went 10 – 14 years without brushing your teeth and then visited the dentist, I promise that he or she would want to put you under anesthesia for some major work. That is what vets do when we perform dental work on pets every couple of years.

Veterinarians often refer to such procedures dental cleaning or teeth cleaning. These terms sell the procedures short. What we do, in fact, is ultrasonically remove dental calculus and infection above and below the gum line. We assess and treat dental pockets, odontoclastic resorpitve lesions (severely painful enamel defects in cats), and periodontitis (infection of the ligaments and structures surrounding the teeth). We evaluate fractured (chipped) teeth, and work to correct gingivitis (gum infection). We often take dental X-rays. We sometimes extract hopelessly compromised teeth. We screen for oral cancer. And, last of all, we clean the teeth.

Anesthesia-free teeth cleaning involves removal of calculus from the teeth themselves. It is teeth cleaning, and nothing more.

For most animals, anesthesia-free dental work is no substitute for the real thing. However, Hedy, your pet may be an exception. If you brush your pet’s teeth daily and regularly have dental calculus removed from the teeth before it can spread under the gums, you may protect your pet from serious dental issues.

Nonetheless, I urge you to check the credentials of the person working on your dog’s teeth. I have met several people who perform the procedure. Some of them knew what they were doing. Others displayed an appalling lack of knowledge.

No matter what, I recommend that you have your vet perform regular thorough oral exams. And keep brushing your dog’s teeth!

Share this entry with your pawple anywhere:

See related Vet Blog entries:
06/19/08

What Questions Should I ask my Vet Before Surgery?
Dr. Eric Barchas, DVM

scalpel1.jpgMy six-month-old, 3.5 pound Chihuahua is due for
spaying. I am nervous about complications. How do
I know if my vet does a good job? What is the
difference between my vet and a pet pal
rescue-spaying clinic (it is less expensive)?

Robin
St. Petersburg, FL

This is a very good question. The overwhelming majority of spays and neuters performed by veterinarians do not lead to major complications. Nonetheless, the risk of complications exists any time a pet undergoes surgery. Your desire to minimize that risk is very understandable.

Here is what I recommend: ask your vet some questions.

Surgeries performed by experienced vets generally have lower rates of complications than those performed by vets fresh out of school. Ask your vet how long she has been practicing. Ask her how many spays she has performed.

As well, surgical safety precautions vary widely among veterinary facilities. Does your vet run blood tests before surgery to ensure that your pet’s organs are functioning properly? Does she give IV fluids to help support blood pressure? Does she monitor heart rate, blood oxygenation levels, and blood pressure continuously throughout surgery? Does she provide thermal support to prevent low body temperature? Is she aggressive and proactive about treating pain? Does she use the most modern and safest forms of anesthesia?

The only way to know whether your vet does these things is to ask her. You can ask the same questions at the rescue-spaying clinic. Once you have the answers you will be able to make an informed decision that is in the best interest of your dog.

Share this entry with your pawple anywhere:

See related Vet Blog entries: